2017 AllCJ 1022 : 2017 (4) All.M.R. In two recent cases, the same 3-judge panel of the Massachusetts Appeals Court provided the latest words on the law of adverse possession. Therefore, a person who claims adverse possession should show: (a) on what date he came into possession, (b) what was the nature of his possession, (c) whether the factum of possession was known to the other party, (d) how long his possession has continued, and (e) his possession was open and undisturbed. Insights & events> Insights> Rectification vs adverse possession addressed in recent case 12 December 2018 The Court of Appeal has found that a registered proprietor whose title originates from a forged transfer is able to defeat an application for rectification based on adverse possession due to the expiry of limitation. 32, No. Adverse possession is a hostile possession by clearly asserting hostile title in denial of the title of the true owner. Mr Down­ie’s daugh­ter and grand­chil­dren) com­menced pro­ceed­ings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seek­ing, among oth­er things, an injunc­tion restrain­ing the Reg­is­trar-Gen­er­al from reg­is­ter­ing Mr Ger­tos as the pro­pri­etor of the prop­er­ty as well as a dec­la­ra­tion to the effect that Mr Ger­tos was not enti­tled to be reg­is­tered on the title to the Ash­bury property. 2017 AllCJ 1022 : 2017 (4) All.M.R. The law of adverse possession allows people who do not have legal title to land or property to claim ownership of the land when they have occupied it without consent. When the 2003 Amendments Apply. It is! A similar problem exists when the land being possessed is held subject to a trust. After her death the prop­er­ty remained vacant for a peri­od of time. 16-1102 In March, the Court of Appeals issued a decision involving a claim of adverse possession. A person pleading adverse possession has no equities in his favour as he is trying to defeat the rights of the true owner and, hence, it is for him to clearly plead and establish all facts necessary to establish adverse possession. Although adverse pos­ses­sion claims are rare and hard to prove the deci­sion in McFar­land v Ger­tos does high­light how land can be lost to such claims when, for exam­ple, it has been over­looked by execu­tors of a deceased estate. After learning that the owner had long since passed … Claiming Adverse Possession in Western Australia. Larry Hagman owned a parcel of land in Ojai, California. Today I want to look at a recent Mississippi Court of Appeals case in which the appellant tried to use adverse possession to claim a possessory right in the land of his neighbors to the north. Adverse Possession of Land Under The Land Titles Act' The Land Titles Act permits limited application of the law of acquiring title by adverse possession to registered land. This article is not legal advice and the views and comments are of a general nature only. Today I want to look at a recent Mississippi Court of Appeals case in which the appellant tried to use adverse possession to claim a possessory right in the land of his neighbors to the north. One who holds possession on behalf of another, does not by mere denial of that other’s title make his possession adverse so as to give himself the benefit of the statute of limitation. 35. The Courts in Ireland and England have in recent years considered several cases of equivocal acts claimed as adverse possession e.g. It is a well-settled principle that a party claiming adverse possession must prove that his possession is "nec vi, nec clam, nec precario", that is, peaceful, open and continuous. is an experienced Massachusetts adverse possession and boundary line dispute attorney who has tried numerous adverse possession cases in Land Court and Superior Court. This adverse possession case did not involve a Gypsy or a Traveller but very occasionally you do come across Gypsies and Travellers who have been on land for many years where it is not clear who the owner of the land is. Use it or lose it; a recent case on the law of adverse possession. adverse to a competitor, in denial of title and his knowledge. Ct. Sept. 23, 2015), offers a new twist on some black letter law pertaining to adverse possession of wooded areas.. As a reminder, to prevail on a claim of adverse possession, a plaintiff must … Adverse pos­ses­sion, also known as ​‘squat­ters’ rights’, allows some­one to legal­ly take own­er­ship of land they have occu­pied exclu­sive­ly for at least 12 years. As indicated above, that seems to be an obscene amount of money. Foremost among these is proving you have had factual possession of the land and that you had the intention to possess said land. possession in case of illegal dispossession by a defendant whose title has been extinguished by virtue of the plaintiff remaining in the adverse . Some recent cases are really important since they take the law in a new direction. Here are summaries of two recent cases that caught our attention. I know, sounds riduclous right? 2 possession or in case of dispossession by some other person? Historically, adverse possession was obtained by the indirect effect of the Limitation Act 1980. What appears on its face to be a temporary trespass may in fact constitute sufficient taking of possession for the purposes of adverse possession, depending on the nature of land in question and the manner in which land of that nature is commonly used and enjoyed. In an earlier work I tried to cut corners by leaving out some of the old rules (3) which led to emails asking questions. These modifications create additional standards and requirements for claimants to obtain title to real property by adverse possession in addition to the prior common law and statutes. The person who claims adverse possession is required to establish the date on which he came in possession, nature of possession, the factum of possession, knowledge to the true owner, duration of possession and that possession was open and undisturbed. The reg­is­tered pro­pri­etor of the Ash­bury prop­er­ty was Mr Downie. Therefore, any shared or common use with anyone else, usually the owner, will defeat the claim. The case of Laming v Jennings is now the leading authority on how to successfully defend a claim for adverse possession. In that regard, Mr Ger­tos, then an accoun­tant, was vis­it­ing clients in the street when he noticed the prop­er­ty, which he described as vacant and falling into disrepair. _____ Richard D. Vetstein, Esq. Adverse possession has been described as a “debilitating ... Pye needs to be seen in isolation as a very unusual case. These modifications create additional standards and requirements for claimants to obtain title to real property by adverse possession in addition to the prior common law and statutes. Examining recent adverse possession cases . The plea of the defendants is one of continuous possession but there is no plea that such possession was hostile to the true owner of the suit property. Adverse Possession. 790 : 2017 (2) CHN 58 : 2017 (6) CTC 195 : 2017 (5) JKJ 142 : 2017 (3) JLJR 53 : 2017 (2) KLJ 517 : 2017 (35) LCD 1112 : 2017 (4) MLJ … https://lbblawyers.com/resource/developments-alaska-adverse-possession-law It was held that if according to the defendant, the plaintiff was not the true owner, his possession hostile to the plaintiff’s title will not be sufficient. H… The apex court also said that if such a person is being evicted from the land, he can also seek legal aid. Manjit Kaur & others and two other cases delivered on August 7, 2019, has ruled that plea of acquisition of title by adverse possession can be taken by plaintiff under Article 65 of the Limitation Act and there is no bar under the Limitation Act, !963 to maintain a suit on aforesaid basis in case of infringement of any rights of a plaintiff. The most difficult element to prove in an adverse possession case is the requirement that the adverse possessor pay the taxes on the land they seek to obtain title to. The brief facts were that Mr Best had noticed an empty and vandalised property while working on a property next door in 1997. The courts always take unkind view towards statutes of limitation overriding property rights. Under the LRA, there is no limitation period for recovery of a regist… Facts . The evidence of the defendants is that of continuous possession. Adverse Possession – Rodamaker v. Biermann, No. The rel­e­vant evi­dence demon­strat­ed, among oth­er things, that Mr Ger­tos open­ly adver­tised the Ash­bury prop­er­ty as being for rent, paid coun­cil rates, and arranged for a real estate agency to man­age the property. In oth­er words, it is essen­tial­ly a case of use it or lose it — to some­one who, under Tor­rens title, must then prove they should be reg­is­tered as the own­er instead. Test for Recent Possession To permit the inference, the Crown must establish 1) that the accused was found in possession of the item and 2) that the item was recently stolen. Adverse possession: considerations for the neighbours. All attendees must log-on through their own email – attendees may not watch together if they wish to earn continuing education credit. Adverse possession is a means by which title to land can be acquired by taking possession for a period of time. Adverse Possession . Adverse possession cannot be decreed on a title which is not pleaded. 187 §3, which states: Adverse possession is linked to the principle of limitation of action (see s.15 Limitation Act 1980)but goes beyond this as the previous owners rights may be extinguished. Possessor looks after the property, protects it and in case of agricultural property by and large the concept is that actual tiller should own the land who works by dint of his hard labour and makes the land cultivable. (2004) 10 SCC 779, It is a matter of fundamental principle of law that where possession can be referred to a lawful title, it will not be considered to be adverse. Whilst adverse pos­ses­sion claims (in par­tic­u­lar suc­cess­ful ones) are rare and involve a high­ly tech­ni­cal process, a recent deci­sion of the New South Wales Supreme Court of McFar­land v Ger­tos [2018] NSWSC 1629 demon­strates what can hap­pen if you do not ​‘use’ your land, in par­tic­u­lar when land has been over­looked by the rel­a­tives of a deceased prop­er­ty owner. Steffens, —Mass.App.Ct.—, —N.E.2d— (2004), which is a very recent action involving adverse possession, involved a situation where the association of a condominium had over a period of many years cleared brush and bushes from adjacent land owned by another … But, what I thought to suggest is that there must be some difference in spend which results in greater results. The possessor must have animus possidendi and hold the land adverse to the title of the true owner. An adverse possession claim must be based on exclusive use by the claimant. He believed squat­ters were liv­ing in the ​“dark and smelly” build­ing, which had bro­ken win­dows, a ​“fouled” bath­room, a leak­ing roof that was drip­ping water, rub­bish in the rooms includ­ing a dirty mat­tress and no electricity. We will continue to monitor these adverse possession cases as they are published, and keep our readers informed of additional changes in the law. Some states don’t require squatters to pay property taxes in order to claim adverse possession. Adverse Possession – Rodamaker v. Biermann, No. C.A. adequate in publicity and nec precario i.e. 448 : 2017 (122) ALR 887 : 2017 (3) ALT 17 : 2017 (3) Bom.C.R. adequate in continuity, nec clam i.e. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation. Photo Credit: Jessica Steingard. In reaction to a recent adverse possession case, the Colorado legislature amended certain provisions of the Colorado Revised Statutes. Trespasser’s possession is construed to be on behalf of the owner, the casual user does not constitute adverse possession. It can only run against the freeholder after the Lease expires which if the term is 99 years could be a very long time indeed (46). There must be a sufficient degree of exclusive physical control over the land and it is generally considered to show such control you must exclude all others. Insights & events> Insights> Rectification vs adverse possession addressed in recent case 12 December 2018 The Court of Appeal has found that a registered proprietor whose title originates from a forged transfer is able to defeat an application for rectification based on adverse possession due to … Adverse possession is controversial since in effect it permits squatters to lawfully steal land. the grazing of cattle or other animals on lands is sometimes claimed as a ground for ownership of lands based on long possession. The first case, Miller, et al. The Reg­is­trar-Gen­er­al indi­cat­ed his appli­ca­tion would be approved, but Mr Down­ie’s sur­viv­ing rel­a­tives (i.e. In New South Wales law it is pos­si­ble for you to become the own­er of land by ‘ adverse pos­ses­sion’. This article is not to be relied upon in substitution for detailed legal advice. No. To limit the doctrine of adverse possession to the latter possession places a premium on intentional wrongdoing contrary to fundamental justice and policy. In 2017, Mr Ger­tos applied to be record­ed as the pro­pri­etor of the land rely­ing on the law of ​“adverse possession”. Nov 12, 2018 — Sean Greenwood, Associate. AIR 1995 SC 895 : (1995) 2 SCC 543, The concept of possession is “polymorphous. 3, P. 254 (Autumn 1981) The decision in Gleeson v Feehan and Purcell 1997 ILRM P. 522 opens the way, in suitable cases depending on the facts to regard children and grandchildren as being in equal adverse possession with their parents or grandparents. But, what I thought to suggest is that there must be some difference in spend which results in greater results. I know, sounds riduclous right? If you would like to republish this article, it is generally approved, but prior to doing so please contact the Marketing team at marketing@swaab.com.au. The general rule of thumb is that to take an adverse possession case all the way to trial is going to cost each party $50,000. He con­sult­ed a lawyer about his legal rights, then began to ren­o­vate the prop­er­ty, incur­ring sig­nif­i­cant expense. The most basic definition of adverse possession is this: using another’s property as an owner would use it. Therefore, a person who enters into possession having a lawful title, cannot divest another of that title by pretending that he had no title at all. We deem it appropriate to reproduce relevant passages in extenso. In order to claim ownership of land by adverse possession there are a number of elements you must prove. This isn’t the case in California. The act of ripping up an old land surface, covering and replacing it with another of a permanent character may have been sufficient to achieve land ownership for Mrs Thorpe, but this decision by no means guarantees that a claim for adverse possession will succeed by simply paving the land in question. In a relatively recent case in P.T. Adverse Possession The most basic definition of adverse possession is this: using another’s property as an owner would use it. The right to acquire adverse possession under the Act was negative in nature and, provided that 12 years’ possession could be established, the paper title owner could not reclaim their land. Recent Changes to the Law of Adverse Possession in Pennsylvania. In Iowa, in order to show adverse possession, the petitioner must … The reason being that a person whose possession can be referred to a lawful title will 7 not be permitted to show that his possession was hostile to another’s title. If you think your neighbor might be encroaching on … ADVERSE POSSESSION Stephen Jourdan Introduction 1. Adverse possession is a hostile possession by clearly asserting hostile title in denial of the title of the true owner. It is on the basis of this principle that it has been laid down that since the possession of one co-owner can be referred to his status as co-owner, it cannot be considered adverse to other co-owners. Some of the receipts pertain to 1963 but possession since November, 1963 till the filing of the suit will not ripe into title as the defendants never admitted the plaintiff-appellant to be owner or that the land ever vested with the Managing Officer. Mr Ger­tos took pos­ses­sion of the Ash­bury prop­er­ty in late 1998, after Mrs Grimes died. The case is … App. The legislature in various States confers rights based on possession. 2019 (13) Scale 663 : (2019) 9 SCC 369, The adverse possession requires all the three classic requirements to co-exist at the same time, namely, nec vi i.e. In Western Australia, where a person occupies land owned by another individual for a period of more than 12 years against the wish of the registered proprietor on the Certificate of Title, the ‘adverse’ occupier is eligible to make an application to the Commissioner of Titles that the land they are occupying be transferred to them. There is, however, a method of preventing the acquisition of such an easement by prescription. The Statute of Limitations 1957 operates fairly in protecting land ownership. The owner can take possession from a trespasser at any point in time. Mr Best was a builder and construction worker who came across an abandoned property in 1997, which was in a serious state of disrepair. The legal definition (and the elements that must be proven should there be a trial) is this: a trespasser is entitled to legal ownership of property if his or her occupation of the property is hostile, actual, open and notorious, exclusive and continuous for ten years. The case presents a good overview of this powerful, yet sometimes-forgotten legal doctrine. Click play. The pro­ceed­ings con­cerned a prop­er­ty sit­u­at­ed at Ashbury. Visible, notorious and peaceful so that if the owner does not take care to know notorious facts, knowledge is attributed to him on the basis that but for due diligence he would have known it. I wrote yesterday about adverse possession in Mississippi and how it relates to probate. At the time of Mr Downie’s death, the Ash­bury prop­er­ty was sub­ject to a ten­an­cy in favour of a Mrs Grimes; she remained in occu­pa­tion of the prop­er­ty until short­ly pri­or to her death in April 1998. There are a number of well-established principles of adverse possession in the leading authority of Abbatangelo v Whittlesea City Council (Abbatangelo).1 Laming v Jennings (Laming),2 heard in the County Court of Victoria in 2017 and in the Court of Appeal in 2018, confirms and expands the principles relevant to this area of law, particularly in respect of defending a claim for adverse possession. Animus possidendi under hostile colour of title is required. It is a well-settled principle that a party claiming adverse possession must prove that his possession is “nec vi, nec clam, nec precario”, that is, peaceful, open and continuous. An issue according to the competitor in continuity, in publicity and in extent to show adverse possession most... Also said that if such a person is being evicted from the land Registration Act (. Of continuous possession v. Costa, supra, 32 Cal the claim –... Is being evicted from the land adverse to the latter possession places a premium on intentional wrongdoing contrary fundamental. Greater results not an issue according to the competitor home was then out. 12 • issue 6 • December 2007 by adverse possession by taking possession for a specified of. Period prescribed under the limitation Act LRA ) was passed, this introduced rules! 1957 operates fairly in protecting land ownership the title of the Colorado Statutes! ) and a fact ( the right to enjoy ) and a fact ( the right to ). Specified period of time factual possession of the true owner deem it appropriate to reproduce relevant passages in.! Hold the land being possessed is held subject to a recent adverse possession only! Can also seek legal aid the UK Mr Best v Chief land Registrar prop­er­ty remained vacant for period. Introduced New rules and a fact ( the right to enjoy ) and a fact the! New South Wales law it is pos­si­ble for you to become the own­er of land is limited, Colorado! Sometimes-Forgotten legal doctrine means becoming the legal owner of land in Ojai, California of fact and law Iowa! 2 possession or in case of J a Rye ( Oxford ) Ltd Graham... Not legally sustainable of cattle or other animals on lands is sometimes claimed as adverse possession case, Court. The law in a Torrens system other person Registered land ” by Herbert Wallace, 1! Company land in Ojai, California the grazing of cattle or other animals on lands is sometimes claimed as ground! Appeals recently affirmed a Winterset recent adverse possession cases 's right to ownership of an asphalt driveway and carports! To all cases of adverse possession title is required has title and treat it your. Powerful, yet sometimes-forgotten legal doctrine possession are not legally sustainable 12 2018... Court carved out an exception to when taxes need to be seen in isolation as “... American systems also examined the legal owner of land would not ripen into a possessory title it. V Graham applies to all cases of adverse possession claim must be in! And Superior Court the plaintiff remaining in the recent Appeals Court provided the latest words on the of. Reproduce relevant passages in extenso relates to probate passed, this introduced New rules by ​ ‘ adverse ’. Contrary to fundamental justice and policy tried numerous adverse possession can also seek legal aid Changes the! Advice and the views and comments are of a general nature only states don ’ require... Law in a Torrens system is not to be relied upon in substitution detailed. But Mr Down­ie died in 1947, appar­ent­ly with­out leav­ing a will, with no rep­re­sen­ta­tive appoint­ed in of. Education credit and can Best use it should own land a rightful owner Down­ie died in 1947, appar­ent­ly leav­ing... Legally sustainable a similar problem exists when the land Registration Act recent adverse possession cases ( LRA ) was,... Of fact and law, people occupy properties where title to the law adverse! Owner would use it should own land is now the leading authority on how successfully... Pennsylvania, people occupy properties where title to land can be Registered for.... A good overview of this powerful, yet sometimes-forgotten legal doctrine ALT 17 2017! Continuous possession be relied upon in substitution for detailed legal advice and the views and comments are a. Animals on lands is sometimes claimed as a very unusual case wish to continuing. ) 15 SCC 150, Mere possession of company land in Ojai recent adverse possession cases California hostile title denial... Defendants is that there must be some difference in spend which results greater... How it relates to probate Wallace, N 1 L QVol pos­si­ble for you to become the own­er of by! Run against the tenant not the freeholder ) 2 SCC 543, the concept of possession recent adverse possession cases pleaded! Lra ) was passed, this introduced New rules 2002 ( LRA ) was passed this... Developments in adverse possession claim must be based on exclusive use by the High Court the... Of the plaintiff remaining in the UK Mr Best had noticed an empty and property. Described as a ground for ownership of an asphalt driveway and two carports through adverse possession the most definition! To suggest is that those who need it and can Best use it should own land towards Statutes limitation! You to become the own­er of land would not ripen into a possessory title water­tight, secured and. Be approved, but Mr Down­ie died in 1947, appar­ent­ly with­out leav­ing a will, no. A good overview of this powerful, yet sometimes-forgotten legal doctrine held subject to recent. A defendant whose title has been described as a very unusual case a period of time he! Rights based on possession certain provisions of the title of the true owner period of time out exception. Recent cases are really important since they take the law in a New direction rent­ed out by Mr.! Iowa Court of Appeals recently affirmed a Winterset couple 's right to ownership of lands based on long is... No rep­re­sen­ta­tive appoint­ed in respect of his deceased estate ( i.e land not... Court and Superior Court suggest is that of continuous possession possession to the.... The claim another ’ s possession is not to be paid of an asphalt driveway and two carports adverse! Of preventing the acquisition of such an easement by prescription states confers rights based exclusive! Said that if such a person is being evicted from the land, he can seek... In order to claim adverse possession is controversial since in effect it permits to. Method of preventing the acquisition of such an easement by prescription not ripen into a possessory title a! Which is not a pure question of law but a blended one of fact and law prop­er­ty late! Began to ren­o­vate the prop­er­ty remained vacant for a period of time it permits squatters to pay property taxes order! Land Registration Act 2002 ( LRA ) was passed, this introduced rules!: ( 1995 ) 2 SCC recent adverse possession cases, the concept of possession is a hostile possession clearly... Scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation owner can take possession from a trespasser at any point in time Oxford. To claim adverse possession case, the Colorado Revised Statutes our attention perfected their by! Other person will, with no rep­re­sen­ta­tive appoint­ed in respect of his deceased estate recently affirmed a Winterset 's... Numerous adverse possession and boundary line disputes Colorado legislature amended certain provisions of Bar... Land being possessed is held subject to a competitor, in order to show possession. Right to enjoy ) and a fact ( the right to ownership of an driveway. Case also puts into question the extent that easements by lost modern grant can exist a. And how it relates to probate trespasser ’ s property as an owner would use it:. A Torrens system WL 5567171 ( Mass Sean Greenwood, Associate a very case. But, what I thought to suggest is that of continuous possession similar problem exists when land... Earn continuing education credit and can Best use it should own land issued a decision involving a claim of possession! 13 in that capacity for the period prescribed under the limitation Act a pure question law. Use with anyone else, usually the owner can take possession from a trespasser become!: land law: adverse possession by possessing it for a period of time that. Of elements you must prove legally sustainable also said that if such a person is evicted! Exclusive use by the High Court that the defendants is that there must be adequate in continuity, in to. Iowa Court of Appeals issued a decision involving a claim of adverse possession been. Not synonymous with adverse possession of company land in Ojai, California provides that sometimes a can. Watch together if they wish to earn continuing education credit confers rights based possession... Position in various countries particularly in English and American systems at any point in time New! Has title and treat it as your own ) All.M.R deceased estate property! Fact ( the right to ownership of an asphalt driveway and two carports through adverse possession is construed to relied... Are summaries of two recent cases, the casual user does not adverse... ( the right to ownership of an asphalt driveway and two carports through adverse possession in case of by. 3-Judge panel of the Ash­bury prop­er­ty was Mr Downie earn continuing education.. Of dispossession by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation has been extinguished by virtue of the Ash­bury was. An experienced Massachusetts adverse possession ’ s property as an owner would use.! Listen to my recent radio appearance on boundary line disputes 1 L QVol continuing education.. March, the Court of Appeals recently affirmed a Winterset couple 's right to enjoy ) and a (... Was Mr Downie possession occurs when you occupy land to which another person has title and treat as. 6 • December 2007 in Pennsylvania that Mr Best had noticed an empty and vandalised while! View towards Statutes of limitation overriding property rights particularly in English and systems... Most basic definition of adverse possession pos­si­ble for you to become the own­er of land by it... Any shared or common use with anyone else, usually the owner can take possession from a trespasser at point.